From John C. Eastman on The Federalist.com (Nov. 2):
Traveled to Belgrade, Serbia, this past weekend as an international observer of the country’s Oct. 25 parliamentary elections. What I witnessed was a remarkably thorough system of election security, administered by election officials representing competing political parties, with multiple safeguards designed to prevent fraudulent voting.
What I also witnessed was an opposition movement seemingly prepared to reject the legitimacy of the election if it lost, based on a carefully prepared preelection narrative that had little connection with reality.
The irony, of course, is that the opposition won, so the anticipated (and feared) protests turned instead to an exuberant celebration that lasted well into the wee hours of the morning.
The Student List, a political movement that emerged from nearly two years of student-led protests against the government of Aleksandar Vučić, won a decisive victory. According to preliminary official results, the Student List received approximately 52.7 percent of the vote, securing 140 seats in Serbia’s 250-member parliament. The governing coalition received approximately 39.2 percent, securing 104 seats. Vučić conceded defeat.
But the election-day rhetoric preceding that victory deserves scrutiny, particularly because it illustrates a dangerous tendency in democratic politics: the willingness to treat elections as legitimate only when one’s preferred candidates prevail.
Preparing Specious Allegations
Before the polls had even opened, representatives of the Student List were already promoting specious allegations that appeared designed to provide a trigger for potentially violent protests should the Student List not prevail on election day.
One involved the voter rolls. Opposition activists complained that hundreds of thousands of registered voters lacked complete addresses, including street names or house numbers. Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty reported that approximately 500,000 registered voters had incomplete addresses, presenting that fact as a potential indicator of electoral fraud.
That sounds alarming — until one considers the realities of rural Serbia. In many small villages, formal street names and house numbers are simply not used in the manner familiar to Americans. And they are certainly much less of a concern when voting is in person rather than by mail. An incomplete street address is not, by itself, evidence of a fictitious voter. Yet the information was pressed by a compliant media as though it were, helping to craft a narrative that might have later served as a trigger if one had become necessary.
Certainly, the voter rolls should be examined for duplicate registrations, nonexistent voters, or other irregularities. But the absence of a conventional street address does not establish any of those things. Treating it as proof of massive fraud, without more, was irresponsible.
……..
Serbia’s Election Safeguards
Serbia’s election procedures contain several safeguards that Americans would do well to study.
First, the polling places I observed were staffed by representatives of both major competing political movements. In most cases, representatives of one or more smaller parties were present as well.
This bipartisan — and frequently multipartisan — participation was not merely ceremonial. Representatives of the competing parties not only actively monitored the voting process but they were the ones actually conducting it, ensuring that the rules were followed and that neither side could easily manipulate the proceedings.
Second, every voter was required to present photographic identification.
The identification documents were carefully scrutinized and compared against a comprehensive precinct voter roll. And unlike in too many U.S. states, there could be no last-minute, same-day additions to the rolls. Election officials verified that the individual presenting the identification was the person listed as eligible to vote.
Third, after identification was verified, the voter was required to sign the voter roll next to his or her name, creating an additional record that the registered voter had appeared and received a ballot.
And fourth, Serbia employs an election security measure that is virtually unknown in American elections: indelible ultraviolet ink to prevent multiple voting.
At the beginning of the voting process, each voter’s right index finger was examined under an ultraviolet light to determine whether the individual had already voted. Before receiving a ballot, the voter’s finger was sprayed with a special liquid visible under ultraviolet light.
The purpose was straightforward. If the same person attempted to vote again, whether at the same polling place or another, the ultraviolet scan would reveal the prior marking.
Another important safeguard was that voting had to be conducted in person. There was no widespread mail-in voting of the sort familiar to Americans. Even Serbian citizens living abroad had to appear personally at designated polling places in Serbian embassies or consulates. And Serbians living in Kosovo — the independence of which Serbia has not recognized — faced an even greater burden: because polling places were not established there, they had to travel into Serbia proper to cast their ballots. The Serbian Republic Electoral Commission confirms that 60 polling stations in the Serbian municipalities of Vranje, Kuršumlija, Raška, and Tutin served voters from Kosovo and 93 overseas polling stations operated in 37 countries.
The combination of photographic identification, a precinct-specific voter roll, the voter’s signature, multiparty election supervision, and ultraviolet marking created multiple layers of protection against fraudulent voting.
No election system is perfect, of course. And a system that works well in the polling places I visited may not have worked equally well throughout the country. Independent Serbian observers reported problems elsewhere, including some alleged failures to use identification checks and ultraviolet marking consistently. [read more]
Good for them! The "indelible ultraviolet ink to prevent multiple voting" is a great idea. The Left would say that all those measures for a secure election is just voter intimidation.
